In May 2026, the Supreme Court of Virginia threw out a redistricting amendment voters had already approved.
A Bedford County supervisor has asked Virginia's appeals court to give the abortion amendment the same treatment.
And her lawyers say Question 1 can be struck down no matter how Virginians vote on November 3.
Virginia Abortion Amendment Lawsuit Heads to the Court of Appeals
Charla Bansley serves as District 3 Supervisor on the Bedford County Board of Supervisors.
She's also the plaintiff in Bansley v. Nardo, the lawsuit aimed at House Joint Resolution 1 – the measure voters see as Question 1.
Liberty Counsel, the Christian legal group led by Mat Staver, represents her.
The Virginia Constitution doesn't let lawmakers rush an amendment onto the ballot.
Once it clears its first legislative vote, a copy has to reach every circuit court clerk in Virginia and go up for the public to read three months ahead of the next House of Delegates election.
Bansley's lawsuit says the House of Delegates never did either one before the 2025 election.
Then the legislature repealed those requirements after the fact.
In July 2026, Campbell County Circuit Court Judge John T. Cook dismissed the case.
He ruled Bansley had no standing, either as an elected official or as a voter.
He also ruled the posting rules weren't mandatory and that the retroactive repeal cured any violation.
A Virginia judge decided the rules for changing the state Constitution are optional.
Liberty Counsel Cites 120 Years of Precedent to Void Question 1
Liberty Counsel's opening brief to the Court of Appeals of Virginia argues Judge Cook got it wrong three times.
First, for 120 years Virginia courts have let ordinary voters sue when lawmakers botch the amendment process, and Bansley is a voter.
Second, Virginia case law demands strict compliance, and the brief says amendment procedures "must be meticulously followed or the amendment will fail."
Third, a retroactive repeal can't erase a violation that already happened.
The brief argues the repeal violates due process by stripping citizens of the right to challenge the government for breaking the rules.
Liberty Counsel asks the court for one remedy – declare HJR 1 void.
The group tried to skip the line in August 2026, asking that the case go straight to the Supreme Court of Virginia.
Instead, it landed in the Court of Appeals.
Staver expects the case to reach the state's highest court anyway once appellate review is done.
Virginia Question 1 Would Write Late-Term Abortion Into the State Constitution
The stakes go far beyond paperwork.
Under current Virginia law, a third-trimester abortion requires three doctors to certify a threat to the mother's life or health.
The Daily Signal's Melanie Israel and Jesse Castrinos report that Question 1 would cut that to one physician's judgment about the "life or physical or mental health" of the mother.
Neither "physical" nor "mental health" is defined.
According to Israel and Castrinos, lawmakers rejected an amendment to protect Virginia's parental consent and notification laws.
They also rejected protections for babies born alive after a failed abortion.
The text doesn't even say "woman" – it says "pregnant individual."
That's the measure the lawsuit says pro-abortion legislators pushed past the Constitution's notice rules.
Virginia Supreme Court Redistricting Ruling Shows a Voter-Approved Amendment Can Fall
The Supreme Court of Virginia has already shown what happens when lawmakers cut corners.
Voters narrowly approved a Democrat-drawn redistricting amendment on April 21, 2026.
On May 8, 2026, the court struck it down 4-3 in an opinion by Justice D. Arthur Kelsey.
The defect there was timing.
The Constitution requires an election between the legislature's first and second votes on an amendment, and the court found the Democrat-led General Assembly never honored it.
Democratic Sen. Mark Warner complained that millions of Virginians had already voted on the amendment, and the court threw it out anyway.
The violation in Bansley's case is different, but the principle is identical.
The Virginia Constitution sets the steps, and skipping them kills the amendment.
Staver puts it plainly: "Voters deserve certainty on a state constitutional amendment before an election, not after."
Virginians are filling out ballots during early voting without knowing whether Question 1 will survive in court.
A No vote on November 3 ends the fight without waiting on a judge.
Democratic Del. Charniele Herring introduced HJR 1, and if her House followed every step the Constitution requires, she should put the proof on the record before Virginians finish voting.
Sources:
- Liberty Counsel, "Legal challenge continues against Virginia abortion ballot measure," Live Action, October 20, 2026.
- Steven Ertelt, "Pro-Life Group Still Fighting in Court to Stop Radical Virginia Abortion Amendment," LifeNews, October 19, 2026.
- Liberty Counsel, "Virginia abortion ballot measure challenge seeks appeal bypass to state Supreme Court," Live Action, August 30, 2026.
- Melanie Israel and Jesse Castrinos, "Virginia Is Considering an Extreme Pro-Abortion Amendment," The Daily Signal, March 26, 2026.
- Katharine Gorka, "Virginia Supreme Court Rules Redistricting Referendum Unconstitutional: A Victory for Voters," The Daily Signal, May 8, 2026.
- Alec Schemmel, "Virginia Democrat who helped lead state's redistricting push also played part in killing it," Fox News, May 8, 2026.

